OPTOMETRY · SEMESTER 2 Clinical Optometric Procedures: Subjective Refraction Visual Optics and Assessment START READING NOTES Contents of This Topic Clinical Optometric Procedures: Subjective Refraction INTRODUCTION CONSIDERATIONS BEFORE SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION INSTRUMENTS FOR SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION STARTING POINT OF THE SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION BEST VISION SPHERE DETERMINATION VISION MONOCULAR BALANCING TECHNIQUES ASTIGMATIC ERROR DETERMINATION Feb 2010, Ve Jackson Cross Figure 2.11 J B2 – 11 Slit Method Figure 2 B2 – 15 BINOCULAR BALANCING TECHNIQUES Phoropter/Trial Frame SECTION B – VISUAL FUNCTION ASSESSMENT Clinical Optometric Procedures: Subjective Refraction CHAPTER 2 – SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION This chapter will include a review of: Considerations before subjective refraction Instruments for subjective refraction Starting point of the subjective refraction Best vision sphere determination Monocular balancing techniques Astigmatic error determination Binocular balancing techniques INTRODUCTION Subjective refraction determines the refractive status of the eye using the patient' input. Subjective refraction is to determine by subjective means, the spherical and cylindrical lenses that are necessary to provide the patient with the best VA with accommodation relaxed. This is termed as subjective refraction. This is determined by responses/ input from the patient. This examination relies completely on the patient’s perceived differences between letters on a VA chart being viewed through each variation in refractive power. It should be noted that since the technique is subjective in nature, it does not always represent the full refractive status of the patient being tested. CONSIDERATIONS BEFORE SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION The discrimination between dioptric changes differs from individual to individual. Some individuals are very sensitive to even the smallest changes in dioptric change. Others are less sensitive and require significant changes in dioptric power for differences in VA to be perceived. According to Benjamin in Borish’s Clinical Refraction (2006) intelligence, past experience, accustomed visual imagery and uncertainty in discriminating between small differences may prevent perfect correlations between the subjective findings and that of the true refractive status of the eye. Some patients may perform poorly on subjective refractions because of the forced/paired choice presentations of lenses being presented. Malingers and tend to mislead the examiner, due to a preference for spectacles as a fashion item, seeking attention, etc. Other factors that should be considered when performing a subjective refraction which could influence the patient’s performance on the subjective refraction include: Health status of the eye Systemic health Use of medications or drugs that may have ocular and visual effects Age of the patient Extended depth of focus of a small pupil International Centre for Eyecare Education Choice of target, its distance and composition Room illumination Physiological pupil size and retinal adaptation Time allowed for discrimination between lens changes INSTRUMENTS FOR SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION Trial Case, Trial Frame (TF) and Phoropter (Fig. 2.1 a, b) and (Fig. 2.2) (It is important to acknowledge that phoropters are expensive and that with the context of the developing world, trial frames are more readily available, however, they have an equal degree of importance especially when conducting binocular vision testing). Figure 2.1 (a) Trial frame Figure 2.1 (b) Trial case The use of the TF and trial case versus the use of a phoropter for the subjective refraction can be based on availability and various other factors including age of patient, refractive status of the patient, compactness of instrumentation, etc. In many cases where a patient presents with high amounts of refractive error, the variation of the phoropter in terms of face form, vertex distance (in some instances) and pantoscopic angle from that of spectacles makes the trial frame the preferred instrument in the subjective refraction. Figure 2.2 Phoropter used in refraction International Centre for Eyecare Education The subjective refraction is a step-by-step procedure involving the patient’s ability to evaluate the clarity of a distance target as a series of paired comparisons of lenses are presented by the examiner. The patient fixates throughout the procedure on a distance target which consists of symbols or letters on a chart or projected chart. The examiner must ensure that this chart is of optimal quality in terms of contrast (should be 100%). Room lighting must allow normal pupil size and retinal adaptation and the chart to be visible. Subjective refractions can be of 2 types, viz. monocular or binocular. The binocular subjective is sometimes preferred because it keeps the eyes in its normal state of binocularity, i.e. both eyes are open during the course of the refraction and the accommodative state is more stable and relaxed for distance viewing. Monocular refractions involve occlusion of the non-tested eye. In monocular refraction, the final end point of the refraction requires accommodative balance and binocular determinations. In cases where a patient is monocular in nature, i.e. strabismus, blind in one eye, uni-ocular, a monocular refraction is only performed without binocular balance. Subjective refraction comprises a host of various techniques. They include: 1. Determination of the best vision spherical Rx and visual acuity 2. Duochrome (monocular balancing of spherical power) 3. Astigmatism determination a. Jackson crossed cylinder technique or b. Fan-and-block technique or c. Humphriss dots d. Stenopaic slit technique 4. Binocular balancing techniques a. Equalization by alternate occlusion or b. Prism dissociation method or c. Fogging method (Humphriss) or d. A method using a Septum (Turville) or e. Polarization method (Vectographic) or f. Dissociated duochrome method 5. Recording of final refractive error with best visual acuity in each eye and both eyes together STARTING POINT OF THE SUBJECTIVE REFRACTION The starting point of the monocular subjective refraction is determined by various objective techniques, including retinoscopy or autorefraction. These findings (lenses) are placed within the trial frame or phoropter. Alternatively, the refraction can begin from the patient’s previous spectacle correction in the trial frame (TF). The starting lenses must be placed in the TF such that the optical centers of the lenses are coincident with the geometric centers of the TF aperture and the entrance pupil of the eyes (Fig. 2.3). This is ensured by adjusting the TF to the patient’s correct interpupillary distance measurement. (It must be noted whether IPD setting should be in the binocular form